December 20, 2007
Deleuze on Simondon and Individuation
Posted by larvalsubjects under Deleuze, Individuation, SimondonI happened to come across Deleuze’s review of Simondon’s L’individuation online (another translation can also be found in Desert Islands and Other Texts). It is interesting to observe how many of the key themes that will make up his later work are already pre-figured here: his critique of the false alternative between formless chaos and supreme individuation, the distinction between singularities and individuals, the role of irreducible inequalities in the actualization of beings, the idea of the individual as a product or result, resonance between divergent series, and so on. This should not, of course, come as a surprise as these themes were already central to Nietzsche & Philosophy (especially the all important sections on quantity and quality in the second chapter), and this review was written in 1966 when Deleuze would have been composing Difference and Repetition (these themes figure heavily in chapter five, “The Assymetrical Synthesis of the Sensible”). At some point I hope we see a translation of Simondon’s L’individuation à la lumière des notions de forme et d’information. I’ve been working through it for some time, but it’s very slow going as Simondon draws heavily on a variety of different sciences, working with their various vocabularies. Out of frustration I’ve even thought about paying someone to translate it, though it would cost a fortune. Being the crass American that I am, my French just isn’t that strong. I have little doubt that this book would have a tremendous impact on English speaking work on Deleuze as well as a variety of other disciplines. Fractal Ontology has been kind enough to translate portions of L’individuation for those who are interested. Be sure to check out their translations of Ruyer as well (Joseph and Taylor, you two really ought to be perfecting your translations and publishing them, not throwing them out into the blogosphere… Though we’re all grateful to you for your work). In addition to these sources, Shaviro of The Pinocchio Theory has a couple of excellent posts working through Simondon’s L’individuation (here, here, and here). The third of these posts is the most interesting for me in relation to my own work. It was these posts that first motivated me to start my own blog, as they were the first writings from the “theory blogosphere” I came across, showing me an entirely new medium of academic engagement and interaction. In addition to this, Nick, of The Accursed Share, has been kind enough to post the first half of Simondon’s On the Mode of Existence of Technical Objects.
January 18, 2008 at 6:16 am
Thanks for the link!
Yeah, it’s a difficult question. We may continue to provide translations on a limited basis, and we’ll almost certainly leave up most of the ones currently available.
Incidentally, we’ve experienced some difficulties in getting works publishe; obviously we feel it is really important that Simondon becomes more widely available.
Other primary sources for Deleuze are scarce in the English world as well… The whole translation question is a large and tricky problem — basically, it’s hard to convince people to support translations of someone who isn’t already popular! However, it’s clear that Simondon is experiencing a kind of resurgence, intensified by the dedicated work of his students in France (people like Barthelemy) and interested theory-people here.
In some ways there’s a similar problem within Deleuzian scholarship itself. Bergen’s book is wonderful, and real, and heavy — something English-language scholarship seems only to reach in brief bursts of clarity.
Wonderful website, by the way! Keep up the good work,
Joe
May 20, 2008 at 1:31 am
Thanks for your support. You encouraged me to take some of my traces of translation onto a higher level. I’ve negotiated with a publisher on L’Inconscient machinique by Guattari, so expect to see it sometime mid-next year. Also, the Simondon is being undertaken by Minnesota Press (I may or may not have a hand in its completion). That’s definitely something to keep your eyes out for!
May 20, 2008 at 1:39 am
Taylor, this is all terrific news! Any word on when the Simondon (L’individuation, I hope) will be available?